Showing posts with label D'Alessandro. Show all posts
Showing posts with label D'Alessandro. Show all posts

Friday, June 23, 2017

Budget History at NYCERS

On April 23, 2017 the NYCERS Trustees adopted the FY-2018 Administrative Budget for the agency. It increased the payroll by $645,000 from $31.06M to $31.70 and the OTPS budget by $900,000 from $20.92m to $21.83M. The F/T head count was increased from 401 to 411. The P/T head count stayed at 35.

Interestingly, the Chair, John Adler, voted against the budget primarily because of the increase in the F/T head count. With the Comptroller's vote the increased head count was adopted. It is a hard budget rule that head count drives costs.

The table below charts out the history of the NYCERS admin budget back to 1986. That was before the 1996 passage of the “corpus funded” budget law.

The 1989 NYCERS budget was the high mark for the NYCERS budget while it was still part of the total city budget. As of July 1, 1996 NYCERS’s budget began to be funded through the assets of the system under the control of the trustees and it was no longer an item in the city's budget. The mayor and the comptroller each have a super vote on the budget resolution in so far as at least one of them needs to vote for the budget for it to be adopted.

In 1996, the non-loan agency head count was 154 F/T employees and 30 college aides. The total budget, both PS and OTPS, was $8.77M. The agency was on life support and the Mayor's Executive Budget had set the NYCERS head count at 146 for 1997.

From 1997 to 2005 with the help of "corpus funding" the agency's F/T staff increased from 154 to 342 along with the original 30 college aide positions. That was a radical increase of 186 positions. In addition in 2000, NYCERS moved into modern office space (133,000 sq. ft.) in downtown Brooklyn.

The NYCERS budget in 2006 had a F/T head count of 342 and a total budget of $34.94M, not including fringe benefit costs. FY-2006 was the last budget I prepared. At that point NYCERS was the best staffed agency in the city and the best funded. If necessary, NYCERS could have performed at a top level indefinitely without any increase in head count.

As of July 1, 2017 NYCERS will have a head count of 411. That is an increase of 69 people over the last 11 years. You would think NYCERS must be functioning flawlessly. It is not.

In 2015, I wrote a critical review of a IT upgrade that NYCERS was planning for the five year 2016-2020 budget cycle. The project is two years through the five year cycle with nothing much done. The only good thing is that the trustees have not let NYCERS spend the full $132M that the staff had requested.

Last year the previous executive director resigned. Adler and the trustees are now in the process of appointing/hiring a new executive director. Let us hope that they find an honest competent person for the position.

History of NYCERS Admin Budget 1987-2018
Fiscal YearF/T CountP/T CountCollege Aides / HourlyPS BudgetOTPS BudgetTotal% Increase
1986205030 $5,916,793 $1,423,743 $7,340,536
1987203030 $6,621,803 $1,881,300 $8,167,220 11.2%
1988223030 $6,621,803 $1,881,300 $8,503,103 4.11%
1989243030 $7,849,731 $1,932,351 $9,782,082 15.4%
1990238030 $8,284,883 $2,578,693 $10,863,576 11.06%
1991229030 $6,826,473 $2,475,205 $9,301,678 -14.38%
1992225030 $6,646,549 $2,216,262 $8,862,811 -4.72
1993223030 $6,858,991 $2,198,882 $9,057,873 2.20%
1994194030 $6,778,541 $2,183,101 $8,961,642 -1.06%
1995167030 $6,202,062 $2,080,504 $8,282,566 -7.58%
1996154030 $6,199,709 $2,573,715 $8,773,424 5.93%
1997200030
1998230030
1999270030
2000290030
20013201330
20023201330
20033341330
20043341330
20053421330 $19,737,687 $14851355 $34,589,042 288.6%
20063421330 $20,255,911 $14,683,855 $34,939,766 1.01%
2007364130 $22,616,783 $14,258,471 $36,875,254 5.54%
2008371130 $23,597,857 $17,259,313 $40,857,170 10.80%
2009371130$25,189,842 18,208,861 $43,398,703 6.22%
2010372120$26,046,827 $17,777,228 $43,824,055 0.98%
2011372120$26,046,827 $18,492,228 $44,539,055 1.63%
20123721220$25,756,827 $18,781,428 $44,538,255 0.00%
2013380530$26,623,635 $17,951,822 $44,575,457 0.08%
2014383530$26,813,635 $18,761,240 $45,574,875 2.24%
2015392530$29,131,972 $18,154,572 $47,286,544 3.76%
2016392530$30,233,989 $19,407,619 $49,641,608 4.98%
2017401530$31,056,080 $20,916,796 $51,972,876 4.70%
2018411530$31,701,410 $21,832,718 $53,534,128 3.00%

Monday, January 2, 2017

Tier 4 Sanitation Workers Being Forced into Tier 6 - also Correction Officers and DA Investigators

Two months ago in the beginning of November, NYCERS started sending letters to a group of Tier 4 Sanitation Workers. The letters stated that NYCERS had incorrectly put them in the Tier 4 Sanitation 20 Year Plan.

This group of Sanitation Workers had NYCERS membership dates prior to April 1, 2012 but had stared working as Sanitation Workers after April 1, 2012, the date that Tier 6 became effective. Originally, NYCERS had correctly placed these members in the Tier 4 Sanitation Plan.

Now NYCERS, ignoring their pre April 1, 2012 membership dates, was stating that since they started working as Sanitation Workers after April 1, 2012, NYCERS was stripping them of their Tier 4 rights and putting them in Tier 6. This was a serious reduction in their benefits. This problem will continue to occur whenever a Tier 4 member becomes a Sanitation Worker, Correction Officer, or DA Investigator.

In New York State the pension rights of state and local government employees are protected from being reduced by the N.Y.S. Constitution, Article V, Section 7. (Klienfeldt v NYCERS, 36 NY.2d 95 (1975) and CSEA v Regan, 71 NY2d 653 (1988))

In addition to violating members' contractual rights guaranteed under the N.Y.S. Constitution, NYCERS provided

  1. no legal analysis supporting this change in procedure,
  2. no pre-deprivation hearing to the members to allow them to challenge this negative decision,
  3. no notice to these members that they have 120 days to file an Article 78 in N.Y.S. Courts to fight this arbitrary and capricious decision.
And finally in classic NYCERS fashion, these letters were not signed.

To rub salt in the wound, NYCERS told these members that all of their Tier 4 Sanitation contributions plus interest would be refunded to them along with the resulting tax liability that would adhere to that refund. Of course, they will have to repay this money with interest in the Tier 6 plan.

I now know that there are comparable groups of Correction Officers and DA Investigators who have been illegally forced in Tier 6. I'm not sure whether they were all given notice.

The NYCERS operating budget is fully funded by the assets of the members and retirees of NYCERS. Why is NYCERS so hostile to the membership? This atrocious legal decision by both D'Alessandro and Mazza is another sign of the total chaos occurring at NYCERS.

Listed below is the new wording added in 2012 which created the Tier 6 Sanitation/Correction membership. A member becomes subject to an article of the Retirement and Social Security Law as of their membership date not their employment date.

25. "New York city uniformed correction/sanitation revised plan member" shall mean a member who becomes subject to the provisions of this article on or after April first, two thousand twelve, and who is a member of either the uniformed force of the New York city department of correction or the uniformed force of the New York city department of sanitation. (Section 501.25 of the NYS-RSSL)

Friday, December 9, 2016

Bad News - NYCERS Reup'd on the Lease for the LIC Disaster Site? No. Mazza is Acting Executive Director as of January 1.

In late spring of 2006 NYCERS signed a ten year lease for a disaster recovery site in Long Island City. It came up for renewal this year and it appears from recent comments by the executive director, Diane D'Alessandro that NYCERS renewed the lease.

At the November 10, 2016 Board Meeting, D'Alessandro announced that by January 1, 2017 some poor souls who work in document control and the mail room will be assigned to work at LIC. There was no mention of the Certificate of Occupancy for the site. Maybe NYCERS finally got the C.O. after ten years. Maybe they are afraid to say so because then they would have to admit it took them ten years to get it.

I don't understand how DC-37 has agreed to let their members to be permanently exiled to such a dump. You can be sure none of D'Alessandro's buddies will have to work there. I wounder if the Post Office will pick up mail from the site?

As far I know there has never been a full fledged test of a recovery plan since workers were not legally permitted on the site. I have no idea how NYCERS has been able to safely run their file backup system at this site when there is no permanent staff at the site. As far as I know there is no plan B.

I guess NYCERS had no option but to renew the lease for five years.

Well D'Alessandro will be gone on January 1. It will be someone else's mess then. Oh, maybe Mazza can solve this problem.

Saturday, October 8, 2016

A Word of Caution About Selecting the New NYCERS Executive Director

Just in case anyone is entertaining the thought of appointing Karen Mazza as the new executive director of NYCERS, including Mazza herself, let me refresh your memory about her illustrious career.

In 1990 I was appointed executive director at NYCERS after 17 years with the agency. In that position I had steady contact with the NYCERS Chair and other NYCERS trustees. At that time it was common for the Mayor to appoint the Finance Commissioner as the Chair of NYCERS.

In 1993 Mazza went to work for the Mayor's Pension Unit at the Finance Department. That unit supported the Commissioner with his/her duties as NYCERS Chair. In that position she worked for an attorney named Norm Rosner who was the Commissioner's alternate at the NYCERS Board. Rosner made it clear to me that Mazza was not an effective employee but gave no details. At the time I did not appreciate his insight into this woman. In hindsight, it is quite clear why he held her in such low esteem. She left Finance in 1994 and went to work at the Comptroller's Office.

In 1991 Leo Vallee and I began writing procedural descriptions for all newly passed pension legislation that impacted NYCERS. These write ups are still being used today. At that time NYCERS had an old time permanent staff lawyer who thought he was a brilliant legal writer. Unfortunately he was not. He was, however, honest.

In 1997, I hired Mazza as an administrative staff analyst. I was hoping we would get help with the analysis of the pension legislation along with other in-house legal issues. Because of the 1996 legislation giving NYCERS budgetary independence, I was legally prohibited from hiring lawyers in legal titles unless I had approval from the Law Department. The Law department was not about to give NYCERS that approval.

Unfortunately, Vallee and I had to continue writing the legislative descriptions because Mazza was also not able get the job done. This was a warning sign that Mazza was not an astute analytical attorney.

Falsifying Time Sheets

In 2000, Mazza gave birth to her second child. Also in 2000 we moved into the new office site in Brooklyn. She returned from maternity leave in late 2000. She returned to 8:00-3:45 work schedule. I worked a 9-5 schedule. Her new office had an open glass front as did all managers' offices and was twenty feet down the hall from my office. Whenever I passed her office I would be able to know whether she was in her office or she was on the phone. For the record she was on the phone almost every time I walked by.

In 2001, I began to notice that when I would arrive to work she was not in her office. I would eventually find her after 9:30 or later. She was one of the top three managers in the agency. Managers have a certain leeway with their schedules in that a manager can be make up time at the end of the day if he/she comes in late in the morning. She, however, was meticulous about dashing out the door at 3:45 hoping I would not see her.

One of my duties was to sign off on the time sheets of all of my direct reports which Mazza was. When I became aware of her absences at the beginning of the day, I started to closely cross check her time sheets with the days when I knew she was late and found that she was falsely recording her starting time as 8:00 when she very often was not arriving until 9:30 or later.

To double check what I had found, I examined the security system which records when all employees enter the working area of the office. Sure enough as another sign of her dishonesty, on the days that she was late she would make sure she did not swipe her security access card. She instead would tell the security guard on the front desk that she had forgotten her card and ask him to buzz her in through the security door. This meant that there was no trace in the security system of when she actually arrived.

I should have fired her at this point.

In retrospect, it was the worst mistake I made while running NYCERS. Foolishly I gave her a second chance. I spoke to her about what I had discovered. She tried to deny it. I told her it had to stop and that I would be closely monitoring her time sheets. From then on she knew I was watching her like a hawk. This was not a good situation.

In addition, in a regular weekly managers' meeting I made it very clear to the all managers that they had to swipe through security every day and if they forgot their card that they had to sign in with Security and mark their time. I got a few funny looks but Mazza knew I was talking about her.

Perjury and Fraud

Subsequently in early 2004 during the hiring process for a new HR director Mazza enabled Felita Baksh to falsify her writing sample which was crucial in my decision to appoint Baksh as the NYCERS HR director. This was in addition to the help that she gave Baksh with her resume.

As everyone at NYCERS has come to know, it is a law of nature that Baksh/Ramsami/DiLorenzo can not write a grammatically correct sentence never mind a two page essay. As a cruel twist of fate, the one HR staff member who unknowingly observed Mazza and Baksh rig the writing sample was eventually fired by Mazza and Baksh. This was after Conflict of Interest Board had fined Baksh for using this employee's credit card to buy furniture.

Later in 2004 Mazza conspired with the DOI investigator, Carol DeFreitas, who was investigating Baksh's appointment. DeFreitas was Martha Stark's "man" on staff at DOI. DeFreitas was literally her employee on assignment at DOI. I need not say anything more about Stark. Together Mazza and DeFreitas were able to supress any mention of Baksh's lying under oath or the false writing sample.

While one trustee forwarded the perjury charge to DOI, there was never any follow up.

Retaliation Against My Wife

After I was fired in March of 2005 Mazza was involved with creating trumped up charges against my wife which lead to her being demoted. Over the next ten years Mazza was a driving force behind placing my wife in position where she had no work assignments and ensuring that any attempt to give her work was blocked. In 2015 my wife had to resign because of health reasons. Over the ten years she had developed sever colitis and had a major heart attacked which almost killed her.

Just a Bad Lawyer

I previously mentioned that Mazza is a incompetent lawyer. In 2008 she was so unable to handle pension issues that she had NYCERS issue a $100K per year no-bid contract to a former law Department staffer to do her work. This went on for 4 or 5 years.

In 2008 Mazza lawyer began harassing the Tier 4 accident disability EMT retirees over the alleged gainful employment issue and forced then to enact legislation to override her incorrect interpretation of the disability statute. She also managed to deny a disabled EMT worker her rightful disability benefit.

When the Workers' Compensation Offset issue arose in 2012, she was in the fore front of crucifying Tier 3 retirees who were receiving disability benefits. Who can forget her words when she was cutting disabled pensioners' checks to $10 a month "we're trying to leave them with something in their pocket at the end of the month".

In 2006 NYCERS signed a lease for a disaster recovery site in Long Island City. Mazza handled the lease and all the the contracts for this fiasco. Ten years later the site still does not have a Certificate of Occupancy.

Closing Thought

D'Alessandro, the executive director, has been a nasty empty suit for eleven years at NYCERS. Now, in July, she appoints Mazza as Deputy Executive Director to fill the spot that opened up with the retirement of the person who held the position for ten years. Then two months later in September D'Alessandro announces her own retirement. What do you think is going on?

Friday, September 16, 2016

A Little Good News!

On Wednesday, September 14, the NYCERS executive director, Diane D'Alessandro, announced that she was retiring at the end of December.

Hopefully the exit of this vicious incompetent boss should provide most NYCERS employees with some relief from their daily stress at work. Of course it will create serious concerns for all the equally incompetent flunkies that she has hired over the last 11 years as well as some other specific employees that have done her dirty work during that time. I am referring to Karen Mazza, Felita Baksh/Ramsami/DiLorenzo, Kin Mak, and Liz Reyes among others.

There was a DOI investigation started in response to the Ellen Carton hiring. I suspect D'Alessandro wants to get out of Dodge before the sheriff arrives.

I sincerely hope that the trustees are able to clean house after she is gone. This agency has a totally adequate operating budget as opposed to other city agencies. It should be an example of almost perfect service to members and retirees as opposed to the arrogant dismissive operation that it is.

Assuming D'Alessandro has no pre-2001 NYS/NYC service, her pension will be about $50K/yr. based on a $217K/yr salary and 14 years of service. This is not a smart financial move. Six more years of service and 12% increase in salary would have increased her pension to $97K/yr.

Wednesday, January 20, 2016

What's It Like Having Your Ex Working For You?

In November, 2005, Martha Stark and the other NYCERS Trustees knowingly hired a totally unqualified person off of Shelley Silver's staff to be the executive director of NYCERS. That person was Diane D'Alessandro.

On Monday, November 30, 2015, D'Alessandro hired a woman named Ellen Carton as a "deputy director" of HR at NYCERS. What is significant about this fact is that she was the domestic partner of D'Alessandro for over 18 years.

NYCERS's claims the relationship was legally ended in 2004. I am not sure how you end a domestic partnership as opposed to a marriage.

What rational chief executive hires her ex spouse as a senior HR manager for her organization? You would never hire your current spouse, never mind your former spouse. It is a mind blowing concept. The potential conflicts would make for a fabulous novel but not a well run organization. But, unfortunately, we all know we are not dealing with a well run organization.

It now seems that the NYC Department of Investigation is looking into this story.

Ms. Carton was appointed at a salary of $127,000/yr. There was no public posting for the position. NYCERS states that Ms. Carton is reporting to Ms. Vilma Ebanks, the deputy director of HR at NYCERS. It is unclear what Ms. Carton's HR qualifications are, if any. According to Carton her consulting practice had closed.

In May of 2014, D'Alessandro hired Ms. Ebanks as a "deputy director" of HR at a salary of $115,000. Again there was no posting for that position. Ebanks had worked at DC-37 for many years before moving to NYCERS. Fourteen months later, Ebanks salary was increased to $131,000.

On a side note, It appears that Ms. Ebanks lives with Michael Musuraca. For many years Musuraca represented DC-37 on the NYCERS Board of Trustees. He was on the Board in 2005 when the Board appointed D'Alessandro. In 2009 he went work for a private equity firm, Blue Wolf Capital, but not before he voted to hire Blue Wolf as private equity firm for NYCERS. Here is a little more background on Blue Wolf.

Both of these hirings follows the same pattern that D'Alessandro used when she hired Diane Bratcher.

As of June 30, 2015, the NYCERS HR division was a direct report to the executive director, Diane D'Alessandro. This has been the case since 1998 when I first created the HR division. As of June 30, 2015 Ms. Felita DiLorenzo (aka Baksh/Ramsami) was running the HR division and reported to D'Alessandro.

NYCERS now claims that Ms. Ebanks is the HR director and reports to Ms. Chiarello, the NYCERS deputy executive director. That is the number two person in the agency.

Note: As of June 30, 2017 the HR division is again reporting to the acting executive director, Karen Mazza.

As part of this story, in July of 2013, NYCERS entered into a contract with a small two person firm out of Tempe, AZ. The name of the firm is CWI Coaching & Consulting. The principals of the firm are Bruce and Kathleen Clark. Ms. Clark is the main contact with NYCERS. It is unclear how CWI was chosen to do whatever they are supposed to be doing for NYCERS. The original contract was for $80,000 but it was modified upwards during the year to $130,000.

Ms. Clark claims to have been introduced to Ms. Carton in NY in 2013. Based on Ms. Clark's response to whether D'Alessandro introduced the two, it is reasonable to assume that D'Alessandro made the introduction.

Shortly after that Ms. Carton started working with Ms. Clark on the NYCERS project. That may have the reason for the budget modification.

NYCERS actually paid CWI $129,736 in FY-2014 and $99,965 in FY-2015.

Going forward NYCERS has an open contract with CWI for the FY-2016 through FY-2018 period. The quoted cost for FY-2016 is $140K,000, for FY-2017, $161,000, and for FY-2018, $185,000.

Based on a December 10, 2015 Board of Trustees presentation by the IT deputy director, Liz Reyes, CWI appears to be a big player in the $132M Legacy Replacement Project. Needless to say, Reyes is in the same boat as D'Alessandro.

Renewal of the Lease for the NYCERS Disaster Recovery Site at Long Island City

In late spring of 2006 NYCERS signed a ten year lease for a disaster recovery site in Long Island City. It comes up for renewal this year.

As of today NYCERS still does not have a Certificate of Occupancy for the site. This means that there has never been a full fledged test of a recovery plan since legally workers are not permitted on the site. I have no idea how NYCERS can safely run their file backup system at this site when there is no permanent staff at the site. As far as I know there is no plan B.

NYCERS has an option to renew the lease for up to two five year periods.

What do you think D'Alessandro will do? What do you think the trustees will do?

Friday, January 1, 2016

Big Trouble with NYCEwork

On December 11, 2015 NYCERS filed a breach of contract claim against enChoice, a firm that NYCERS had hired in FY-2008 to implement a replacement system for its then current document imaging system. NYCERS is seeking $1,444,570 in damages plus interest and costs.

Last May I wrote about the lunacy at NYCERS when it comes to Information Technology (IT) issues. I particularly pointed out the serious problems that NYCERS was having with its new document management/workflow system. The following are NYCERS and my comments:

Comment from NYCERS:

RECENT HISTORY Over the past nine years, NYCERS has made significant infrastructure improvements. Document Management NYCERS continues to ensure the preservation and security of all vital records and to promote an environmentally sound approach to document management. This effort includes the incorporation of all incoming documents into the NYCEWORK system in an electronic format and the ongoing digitization of historical paper documents.

In 2014, NYCERS prepared, scanned and indexed over 200,000 incoming documents and converted over 1 million historical records into digital images. Since the inception of the document management project, over 38 million paper records have been imaged, saving approximately $600,000 in document storage fees.

My analysis:

From this quote you would think that document management was introduced during the last few years. In fact, it was there when D'Alessandro walked in the door. The system in place at that time used a software package called Staffware. It was working well but it was being stressed by the volume of documents that NYCERS was dealing with. It actually continued to function up until 2014 when a new software package, Filenet/NYCEWORK, was finally put into production. I wonder where the $600,000 in saved storage fees came from?

Unfortunately, while Staffware needed to be either upgraded or replaced, Filenet runs significantly slower than Staffware did. That in turn has created incremental delays at every step of every process in the agency. It has created havoc with the production levels for all major functions in the agency.

In FY-2008, NYCERS hired the company enChoice to do the upgrade. enChoice is an IBM partner specializing in implementing IBM's document management software, FileNet. NYCERS labeled the upgrade effort "NYCERwork". Over the next four years the NYCERS IT director, Liz Reyes, had enChoice working on this project.

NYCERS paid enChoice the following amounts:

  • $1,609,278 in FY-2008
  • $ 327,141 in FY-2009
  • $ 267,465 in FY-2010
  • $ 25,941 in FY-2011
Then, in NYCERS FY-2013 Annual Report, the agency's executive director, Diane D'Alessandro, made the follow statement:

NYCEWORK: A NEW DOCUMENT MANAGEMENT/WORKFLOW SYSTEM

NYCERS recognizes the imperative to update and link systems that process memberships, evaluate service, calculate pensions, and handle requests for account information as efficiently as possible. In June 2012, after extensive preparations, we launched NYCEwork, our document imaging and workflow system. NYCEwork maintains images of every document in a member’s lifecycle, beginning with the membership application and ending with the final payment of a retirement allowance to the member or survivor benefit to the designated beneficiary. In order to create a complete, imaged record and continue all of the ongoing work that business units handle, the IT team had to ensure that all active and closed work items and every relevant document were transferred from the outmoded Staffware system into NYCEwork, while at the same time accepting new forms and applications for the business units to process.

With the filing of the suit it is now clear to everyone that Reyes failed to properly manage the NYCEwork project.

What is really frightening about this failure is that the suit in no way fixes the problem. The day to day production problems are still there. There are threats to the integrity and security of the documents that have been committed to NYCEwork. Based on NYCERS claim to storage savings I have to asume the original documents have been destroyed. In addition, I know NYCERS's backup and recovery systems are totally ineffective.

And this is the management that wants to spend $132M over five years to do do an IT legacy upgrade.

The NYCERS trustees need to replace the senior management at NYCERS. If they don't, five years from now they will be looking at more breach of contract suits, more broken systems, a $132M in losses (if they are lucky), and five lost years.

Doesn't it ever occur to anyone that D'Alessandro worked for Shelley Silver before she came to NYCERS and that Martha Stark appointed her.

Note:

This is not the first contract suit that NYCERS has brought against an IT firm. At the same time enChoice was ramping up in FY-2008, NYCERS was also working with IBM ($2.36M over two year) to convert the NYCERS file system to a DB2 database system. Reyes again failed with this project and NYCERS subsequently sued IBM. Cleverly IBM settled with NYCERS by giving them a 20% discount on the purchase of hardware and services capped at $1M for a fixed period. NYCERS was only able to utilize $250,000 of the discount before the time period lapsed. These girls are really on the ball.

What is clear is that over the last 10 years the NYCERS administration has failed to put in place a modern relational database system for its applications.

Monday, October 19, 2015

My Wife Resigned from NYCERS in May of this Year

In May of this year my wife resigned from NYCERS about two years shy of the date she would have been able to retire. She started working at NYCERS in the fall of 1998. In December of 2003, she was promoted to Deputy Director of Administration by Milt Aron, the Deputy Executive Director.

Prior to that, starting in 1980, she worked at the Mayor’s Office, the Sheriff’s Office, and the Department of Homeless Services.

In June, 2005 she was demoted by Aron with the explicit approval of Martha Stark, Chair of the NYCERS Board of Trustees and the Finance Commissioner. She was demoted because of her relationship with me. She was forced back to her permanent civil service position and her salary was reduced by $14,000, the amount that she had been given when she was promoted.

From June of 2005 to May of 2015 my wife was given no work. She was told many times that there were strict orders from the executive staff that she was not to be given any work. Many times over the ten years she explicitly asked for work.

On a few rare occasions she was given some significant work but the minute the executive staff became aware of it, the work was stopped. Kin Mak could always be counted on to pass the word along to Karen Mazza about the work assignment.

In 2013 my wife was hospitalized for 12 days with acute ulcerative colitis.

In 2014, while driving to church on Palm Sunday, she had a major heart attack. She almost died on the side of the road. It was incredibly fortunate that she was at a stop sign and that her 16 year old daughter was with her in the car. The EMT’s were there in minutes and were able revive her with a defibrillator. She spent 18 days in the hospital. She was on reduced body temperature protocol for possible brain damage. She had double bypass surgery and another procedure for a defibrillator implant.

Both of these illnesses were directly caused by stress.

After both of these hospital events she returned to work. Both times she asked for work and both times NYCERS executive staff refused to assign her any work.

In the spring of 2015 the stress of being totally marginalized at NYCERS finally became too much of a threat to her health. She reluctantly resigned. At that point her salary was $104,000.

For many years now, I have been writing about the wretched way that NYCERS, and I mean D'Allesandro, Mazza, and Baksh/Ramsami, have treated members, retirees and NYCERS employees. I speak from personal experience.

You can understand why people lie, cheat, and steal for their own personal gain but to be just plain nasty for no good reason is despicable. The only thing I can come up with is that they are so incompetent they think they have to kick every one under them to hide their own failures. Maybe City Hall and the new NYCERS Chair will get tired of them like the previous mayor did with Martha Stark.

Sunday, June 28, 2015

Follow Up on the IT Budget Boondoggle at NYCERS

On March 12, 2015 the NYCERS Trustees approved a $2.25M budget allocation to be squandered on a mindless IT conversion project.

On May 10, 2015, two months later, I released a sharp criticism, of the project.

On May 12, 2015, two days later, the NYCERS executive director, Diane D'Alessandro, released an unsigned memo notifying the NYCERS staff of the fabulous five year IT conversion project.

So after two months D'Alessandro finally decides to let the troops know what she is doing, exactly two days after I point out the insanity of her project. She starts as follows:

As you may know, NYCERS is embarking on a major information technology (IT) and business system project to replace our now 35-year-old legacy pension administration system - PROD, the core of all NYCERS business functions. The project, known as the Legacy Replacement Project (LRP), will affect almost every aspect of our work at NYCERS, taking at least five years to complete.

She carefully describes the vote by the trustees as follows:

At its March 2015 meeting, the NYCERS Board of Trustees conceptually approved the LRP and adopted a budget that funds early project phases.

She also announces an internal PR campaign:

This is major NYCERS project. As a first step, we have begun a series of meetings to brief everyone on the project and to get your input regarding the initial phase of planning.

Without doubt D'Alessanro will be looking to drag in a ton of consultants for this project. She does, however, want to ensure the staff that she supports them totally:

I want you all to know that NYCERS is committed to providing our staff with the resources and support necessary to ensure success at all stages of this project. We will continue to keep you informed and seek your input as we progress.

You can't make this stuff up.

Just for Laughs

As part of the $2.25M, D'Alessandro got $500,000 for a sole source contract with Gartner. Of that amount, $310,000, is supposed to cover the cost of producing a RFP for the vague conversion project. There is nothing vague about its $132M price tag.

So what does Gartner do? They go looking for a recognized public pension expert who has substantial IT background. That probably is a good idea, since they don't particularly know much about public pension systems. Needless to say, neither does NYCERS.

In turn, Gartner contracts with a IT staffing firm to find such an expert.

On May 14, 2015, this firm reaches out to such an expert with the idea of hiring him and assigning him to the the Gartner contract.

On May 18, 2015 the firm calls the expert and describes the assignment. It becomes quickly clear to the expert that this assignment is part of the NYCERS IT conversion fiasco.

I will let you all guess who the expert was.

The expert was kind enough to let the firm know that, in spite of his intense interest in the project, D'Alessandro would never allow him to work on the project.

Sunday, May 10, 2015

Budget Insanity at NYCERS

On March 12, 2015 the NYCERS Trustees approved the NYCERS FY-2016 administrative budget. It was Diane D'Alessandro's tenth annual adiministrative budget proposal as executive director.

The key numbers are listed in the table below. For comparison purposes I added FY-2006, my last budget as executive director, and FY-1996, NYCERS's last budget under the city's budget structure. The 1996 budget was draconian to say the least. You can see from the table that the NYCERS's budget has increased by 43% over the last ten years or 4.1%/year.

NYCERS: Admin. Budget Over the Years

FY-2016FY-2006FY-1996
FT Positions 401342155
PT Positions 35 130
PS $30.2M $20.0M$6.2M
OTPS $19.4M $14.7M$2.6M
Sub-total $49.6M $34.7M$8.8M
Fringe $8.2M $4.1M$0
Total $57.8M $38.8M$8.8M

What is extraordinary about this budget is that it is the beginning of a delusional spending spree on IT upgrades. It is being called the "Legacy Replacement Project". It proposes to spend $132M over a five year period, staring with $500,000 to be paid to Gartner, Inc. and $1.75M to other consultants to be named later. At the meeting D'Alessandro indicated that she was going to pay $310,000 to an outside firm to write a RFP for this "grand" project. Listed below is the five year spending bonanza.

  • 2016 - $ 2.25M
  • 2017 - $ 9.91M
  • 2018 - $27.86M
  • 2019 - $46.00M
  • 2020 - $46.24M

To OMB's credit they complained about the $310,000 RFP. The trustees, however, approved this budget in spite of making noise about the long term cost of the project.

You would think, considering how well funded that the NYCERS budget is, that the NYCERS staff would be able to write their own RFP. But D'Alessandro got that part right, her staff can't do the job.

Of course, without the results of the RFP where did the $132M amount come from.

In fact over the last ten years D'Alessandro should have been standardizing NYCERS applications on a current client/server platform using a relational database system. This process was underway in 2005 when she first appointed. But thankfully the old CICS/VSAM systems were so well made that they have survived long after the point when they should have been retired. Thank God for small favors.

D'Alessandro, unfortunately, was appointed to her current job in 2005 without any prior relevant experience by Martha Stark and a bunch of compromised trustees. D'Alessandro had never managed anyone. She is not a lawyer, nor an accountant, nor an actuary. She had never worked for a pension system and she had absolutely no IT experience. What she was and still is, is grossly incompetent.

To make the situation worse, the current IT director was working as the NYCERS call center manager when D'Alessandro moved her to the agency's IT division in 2007. At that point she had no IT experience either. Six months later D'Alessandro makes her the director of the IT division. It reminds of when Rudy put a key punch salesman in charge of DoITT. She is as incompetent as D'Alessandro.

D'Alessandro submitted a five page justifying her budget proposal. It is a classic example of using a lot of words to create a fog, lots of hand waving and saying nothing except give me $132M. I actually don't think D'Alessandro wrote the summary. Five pages is far too much work for D'Alessandro. It looks like a cut and paste job from some marketing crap.

This is the justification for $132M.

MAJOR PROJECTS

In a continued effort to provide greater operational efficiency, enhanced customer service and improved quality and production, NYCERS is proposing to undertake a major information technology (IT) and business system replacement project that will streamline and consolidate all applications and functions into a single data repository for common use throughout the agency.

The project which will be known as the Legacy Replacement Project (LRP) will be conducted in three stages over a minimum of five years. The LRP will require a commitment of resources to be phased in over that time.

In order to ensure the success of the LRP, NYCERS is proposing two associated projects including a communications project designed to accommodate expanded electronic interaction with clients and a change management project to address staff training, coaching, and leadership development needs.

You can always spot a IT disaster from the start. It has a long time frame and they don't tell you what they are going to do in the first week of the project, the second week of the project, third week of the project,... You get the picture. Oh yeah, it will also cost a lot of money. I will guarantee you that this project will fail.

When I left NYCERS in 2005, NYCERS had one of the best IT departments in the city. The agency had:

  1. between 60 and 65 IT professionals on staff
  2. an integrated mainframe (VSE) and a network system (Windows Server 2003)
  3. all major work operations automated running under CICS using VSAM and DB2
  4. an advanced web site which allowed members and retirees to view their own specific data.
  5. an imaging/workflow system covering all paper based applications for all members and pensioners.
  6. a dedicated document scanning division
  7. a tested computer disaster recovery plan (we were researching a full business recovery plan and site)
  8. a standardized accounting package running on the network supporting both pension and administrative operations
  9. a nightly backup process of all files including the Exchange Server
  10. a project to upgrade major applications to DB2.
  11. an advanced Avaya based call center with its own backup PBX.
  12. a modern customer service center with its own integrated queuing system
  13. an on-site fully equipped training center.
  14. a proximity card system for both time keeping and security.
  15. a separate network system for the security and a full camera subsystem.

Returning to the executive summary, it is not only short on details about the project but it also has a great deal of deceptive information. The following are a few quotes out of D'Alessandro's write-up along with some clarifying comments.

RECENT HISTORY

Over the past nine years, NYCERS has made significant infrastructure improvements.

Document Management

NYCERS continues to ensure the preservation and security of all vital records and to promote an environmentally sound approach to document management. This effort includes the incorporation of all incoming documents into the NYCEWORK system in an electronic format and the ongoing digitization of historical paper documents.

In 2014, NYCERS prepared, scanned and indexed over 200,000 incoming documents and converted over 1 million historical records into digital images. Since the inception of the document management project, over 38 million paper records have been imaged, saving approximately $600,000 in document storage fees.

From this quote you would think that document management was introduced during the last few years. In fact, it was there when D'Alessandro walked in the door. The system in place at that time used a software package called Staffware. It was working well but it was being stressed by the volume of documents that NYCERS was dealing with. It actually continued to function up until 2014 when a new software package, Filenet/NYCEWORK, was finally put into production. I wonder where the $600,000 in saved storage fees came from?

Unfortunately, while Staffware needed to be either upgraded or replaced, Filenet runs significantly slower than Staffware did. That in turn has created incremental delays at every step of every process in the agency. It has created havoc with the production levels for all major functions in the agency.

This is an example of a mismanaged project being put into production so that management doesn't have to say it made a mistake. We saw this problem with the CityTime project.

While we are talking about mistakes, there have been two major IT disasters at NYCERS in the last nine years costing millions of dollars. One was the DB2 project and the other is the infamous Long Island City disaster recovery site. At least when the DB2 project was cancelled, the bleeding stopped. The LIC-DR project is a never ending cancer.

When I left NYCERS in 2005, the IT department with the help of two consultants was slowly converting over our major VSAM files to a DB2 relational database platform. We had already had two significant systems running under DB2 but there was a long term need to shift all major files over to the relational model. Two months after I left the project was cancelled. Subsequently NYCERS entered into a contract with IBM/Blue-Phoenix to do the DB2 conversion. That project dragged on for years, cost millions, and eventually failed. NYCERS even tried to sue IBM but with very little relief.

Business Continuity

The Long Island City business recovery site enables NYCERS to restore business operations and critical applications in the event of a disaster. This ensures the sustainability of operations and reduces the potential for data loss. Business recovery time is within four hours and the data recovery point is within 30 minutes.

From this quote you would conclude LIC-DR is a success. That is not true in any sense.

The lease on the LIC-DR project was signed in 2006 and NYCERS still does not have a Certificate of Occupancy for the site. I have previously written about this mess. It is not clear what is the legal status of having employees on that site.

For the record, the rent at LIC-DR is $530,000 for FY-2016 plus another $400,000 for other ancillary lease charges. The site has serious water leakage, asbestos, and plumbing problem. The lease comes up for renewal in the spring of 2016. Let's see what the decision will be then.

And in this season of delusion, NYCERS is planning a tertiary disaster recovery site. They even started buying hardware ($250,000 in FY-2015) for this mythical site. Some people just don't get it.

Business Process Automation

NYCERS continues to streamline business processes and leverage infrastructure investments to improve service delivery. As a result, NYCERS has achieved efficiencies in areas including loans and survivor benefits. On-line loan processing time has been reduced from 10 business days to five business days.

In this quote D'Alessandro appears to claim to have automated loans and survivor benefits in the last nine years and that the turnaround time on loans has been dropped from 10 to 5 days. Actually in 2005 both loans and survivor benefits were fully automated. The loans were the first applications automated in the early 1980's and also the first application to be integrated into the imaging/workflow system in 2002. In 2005, if you filed a loan application by Tuesday, NYCERS mailed a loan check to you that Friday. You would wonder why D'Alessandro would have made the above statement.

While all this craziness was going on with the great IT upgrade, D'Alessandro also threw in a request for 12 new employees with salaries of $720,000. No explanation was given. This was on top of 6 new employees in FY-2015, again with no explanation. Since 2013 the full time staff has gone from 372 to 401 and part time staff from 12 to 35. Why are there back logs with production work? Can you imagine what A.C.S. could do with that kind personnel increase.

Friday, February 13, 2015

Sheldon Silver, Martha Stark and Glenwood Management

2011 DOI report on Stark

On January 21, 2015 Sheldon Silver was arrested for fraud and conspiracy. In a description of the charges the name of the Glenwood Management Company surfaces in connection with a kickback scheme that Silver dreamed up to funnel fees from a legal firm to him.

NY Times

In one scheme described in court papers, he asked a pair of real estate developers to hire a small law firm, Goldberg & Iryami, which seeks reductions in New York City property taxes on behalf of its clients.

The firm was started by Jay Arthur Goldberg, who decades ago worked as a lawyer for the Assembly, according to state payroll records. Prosecutors said he was Mr. Silver’s counsel.

Mr. Silver received a slice of the legal fees paid to the firm, even though he did no work for the developers; prosecutors said he was paid about $700,000. He did not report the income on his annual financial disclosure forms submitted to the state.

One of the developers was Glenwood Management, according to people familiar with the matter. Glenwood develops luxury apartment buildings in Manhattan, has been an enormous contributor to state politicians and has a significant interest in matters before the Legislature, such as measures dealing with real estate taxation. While receiving fees from the real-estate law firm, Mr. Silver took actions that benefited the developers, prosecutors said.

Strangely enough, the Glenwood Management firm also surfaces on pages 10 to 33 of a June, 2011 NYC-DOI investigative report on allegations about Martha Stark that were pending at the time she was forced to resign in April, 2009.

Beginning in March, 2005 Stark was involved in lowering the tax assesments for Glenwood. Subsequently in January, 2007 she asked Glenwood for a apartment for her domestic partner (DOI never states which one) along with a break in the rent for the apartment. Read in light of Silver's recent arrest connected to Glenwood, the report has a much more powerful impact. Below is a quote from this section of the report.

The juxtaposition of Stark's request for assistance with an apartment for her domestic partner in a Glenwood owned building and the notice of reduction in assessed value of a Glenwood building for that tax year, and the erroneous further reduction that occurred in the following tax year raises, at a minimum, an appearance issue, and gives rise to the question of whether the reductions were some form of assistance related to the assistance given in the provision of an apartment at a modest reduction for the Finance Commissioner's domestic partner.

Attempts to answer that question were made difficult by Stark's repeated refusal to be interviewed by DOl in connection with this investigation. In addition, the explanations for the assessments were hindered by DOF's lack of oversight and recordkeeping related to the assessment process, as the investigation revealed.

Even after the arrest in 2002 of 18 tax assessors, the work of the DOI/DOF Joint Task Force and the representations by DOF that changes were made and that others would be made in the Joint Task Force Preliminary and Final Reports, there remains a lack of internal controls over assessments.

The costs to the City from this lack of oversight is unknown since no reviews were undertaken to determine if properties were undervalued, and no random audits performed and no regular reports even distributed of significant changes in assessed valuation during the period DOl examined. Finance Commissioner David Frankel reports that he has undertaken measures for reviews/audits of assessments, including assigning/hiring personnel to conduct such audits.

The spring of 2005 was also the time of the $1.74B purchase and alleged tax assessment issues in connection with with Met-Life building, NYCERS, TRS, and the Department of Finance.

It is interesting that in October, 2005 Stark, as the NYCERS Chairperson, was instrumental in hiring of Diane D'Alessandro as executive director of NYCERS. At the time D'Alessandro was a special assitant to Sheldon Silver. Prior to that D'Alessandro worked for DC-37 during the Charlie Hughes and Al Diop years.

Friday, September 12, 2014

Recycled Garbage

In June of this year the executive director of NYCERS, Diane D’Alessandro, appointed Diane Bratcher as deputy director of communications for the agency. The position had become vacant when the former director had left to work in the mayor’s office. His annual salary was $150K. I strongly suspect there was no posting for this position.

At the time of this appointment, Bratcher had been working for eleven months as an associate staff analyst at HRA. The hiring salary for new ASA’s is $59,536.

As background, Bratcher graduated from college in 1974. For the next eight years she seems to have been unemployed. In 1982 Bratcher started working for the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility. She worked there until May, 2002. A month later she was hired by the NYC Finance Commissioner, Martha Stack, as an assistant with a salary of $95K.

Three months later in September, Stark was appointed by Mayor Bloomberg as as the chair of the NYCERS Board of Trustees. At that point Stark made Bratcher the director of the pension unit at Finance, replacing another woman who was a veteran city attorney who had worked for many years at both the Finance pension unit and the NYC Law Department.

For the next seven years Bratcher functioned as a submissive assistant to Stark. I make this comment based on my observations of their interactions at NYCERS board meetings from 2002 to 2005.

It has been established by the NYC Department of Investigation that Stark was slicing through numerous female employees during her seven years as the Finance Commissioner among other transgressions. According to several Finance employees Stark’s escapades were common knowledge within the agency. It is reasonable to conclude that Bratcher was also aware of this sexual activity by her boss, Stark.

In March 2005, Stark as chair of the NYCERS Board of Trustees fired me as the NYCERS executive director because I was involved with a woman on the NYCERS staff. We have since been married. My wife, fortunately or unfortunately, still works at NYCERS.

In October 2005, Stark and the other trustees appointed D’Alessandro as the new NYCERS executive director. Bratcher was actively involved with this appointment.

In April 2009, Bloomberg accepted Stark’s resignation and ordered an investigation into her activity at Finance including her predatory actions with respect to female employees.

All three women, D’Alessandro, Stark, and Bratcher, are long time politically active gay women.

In January 2011, Bratcher left Finance. Her salary at that time was $125,847. Assuming she had joined NYCERS, she was eligible for an annual pension of approximately $18,200 but not health insurance.

In May 2012, Bratcher started working at the UN Principles for Responsible Investment. She lasted there until April 2013. She started working at HRA in July 2013. I strongly suspect that she rejoined NYCERS because of opportunity to significantly increase her pension and gain health insurance coverage in retirement.

Assuming that D’Alessandro gave Bratcher the salary of the former deputy director of $150,000, a significant increase over the ASA salary, Bratcher will be able to increase her future pension by at least an additional $2,100 for every year she works at NYCERS. She will also be eligible for retirement health insurance by the end of this year.

In 2006 I observed Bratcher being deposed during a libel suit I filed against Stark and the NYCERS Board of Trustees. It is common practice for people to lie when testifying during a deposition. They conclude that there is no evidence to contradict what they say. Usually they are correct. But it is truly punishing when evidence is produced during the testimony that proves that the person being deposed has just lied.

The following is a portion of Bratcher’s December 13, 2006 deposition:

Q. Your testimony is Murphy tells the trustees that the DOI report is inaccurate. He had the relationship with Browne, but the DOI report is inaccurate, right?

A. Right.

Q. He wants an opportunity to correct the DOI report. You're saying he says nonetheless, he is going to retire?

A. Yes.

Q. Unconditionally?

A. Unconditionally.

Q. He is just going to retire?

A. Yes.

MS. CARROLL: Mark this document as Bratcher Exhibit 5. It is numbered N 0040. (Bratcher Exhibit 5, N 0040, marked for identification, as of this date.)

Q. After Murphy made his statement to the board, he left the room and then there was executive session again?

A. Yes.

Q. It is a fact, is it not, that because Murphy had not agreed to retire, that the board voted that Murphy had to go; isn't that what happened?

A. No .

Q. Would you look at N 00040. Do you see the second paragraph?

A. Yes.

Q. This is from you to Llembellis. Who is Llembellis?

A. Llembellis at that time was counsel to The Bronx borough president and his representative to the NYCERS board of trustees.

Q. You prepared this E-mail and sent it to Llembellis telling her what occurred at the NYCERS meeting?

A. Yes.

Q. The second sentence of the second paragraph, everybody else voted that John had to go and empowered Martha to negotiate that with him. You wrote that?

A. Yes.

Q. You wrote it on March 11, 2005, the day after the meeting?

A. Yes.

Q. It was accurate when you wrote it, wasn't it?

A. Not accurate.

Q. Are you in the habit of writing inaccurate memos, Ms. Bratcher?

MR. MARKS: Objection to the form.

A. I am not in the habit of –

Q. No, you're not. In fact, you're a very capable assistant, aren't you?

A. I think so.

Q. When you do things, they are very carefully crafted, like your analytical summary, aren't they?

MR. MARKS: Objection to the form.

A. Sometimes, usually.

Q. One could think this document, Stark 2, was done by a lawyer it is so direct and on the money as to the issues, right?

MR. MARKS: Are you trying to pay her a nice compliment or ask her a question?

Q. This statement when you wrote it was true and accurate because you don't write inaccurate and untrue statements, do you, Ms. Bratcher?

A. It was inaccurate. No vote was taken.

Q. Is there any reason why you would mis-inform Ms. Llembellis as to what occurred at the trustee meeting?

MR. MARKS: Objection to the form.

A. I didn't mis-inform her.

Q. I am asking you, is there any reason why you would mis-inform Ms. Llembellis and tell her that everybody else voted that John had to go and empowered Martha to negotiate that with him; is there any reason why?

A. No reason.

Q. The Earl who abstains on the decision, who is that?

A. Earl Brown, E A R L.

Q. By abstaining, that means he didn't vote?

A. What happened -- you want me to answer what happened?

Q. It says here, Earl ended up abstaining on the decision. My question to you is, Earl was a trustee at the meeting?

A. Yes.

Q. That is what you're intending to advise Llembellis about?

A. Right.

.

Friday, January 10, 2014

2005 - The Year the Door Closed - Harassing Veterans

The following is a write up concerning veterans benefits at NYCERS. It highlights how NYCERS has changed its treatment of members since 2005.

Background

In 2000 the legislature passed a law allowing members of all NYS public pension plans to purchase military service (Chapter 548 of the Laws of 2000, eff. October 19, 2000, deemed eff. December 21, 1998). This law created Section 1000 of the NYS RSSL. The text of this section is listed below. I was the executive director of NYCERS at the time.

When enacted, the law allowed members who had served in the military during times of war to purchase up to three years of service credit in their NYS public pension plan. The cost was 3% of the 12 months earnings immediately prior to the date of the filing of their purchase application times the number years of military service being purchased.

As part of the implementation process NYCERS started accepting applications from all members who qualified. There was an additional requirement outlined in subsection 3 that the service would not be creditable until the member had been credited with five years of other pension service. At the time, NYCERS did not restrict applications because of this five year service requirement because the application subsections (1 & 2) did not impose this restriction.

Since 2005, the year I was terminated by the NYCERS Board of Trustees, NYCERS has imposed a five credited service requirement upon the acceptance of application under Section 1000. The effect of this requirement is to generally raise the cost to the member for purchasing military service rendered during time of war. This cost increase is even higher for Tier 6 members who must pay 6% rather than the original 3%.

Needless to say in my opinion NYCERS does not have the authority to impose this requirement on these members who have served their country in times of war. Based on Doctors Council, 71 N.Y.2d 669 the trustees do not have the authority to limit benefits without clear legislative direction. There is no legislative time limit on the filing of applications under Section 1000.

Discussion at the Board Meetings

Listed just below is the conversation from two NYCERS board meetings in 2011. The trustee representative for Local 100 of the TWU raises the issue of changing the NYCERS requirement that a member have five years of service credit before he/she can apply to purchase military service.

The TWU rep correctly states that the law does not impose a five year service requirement on the application filing process. He further states that he has been told that the Law Department has directed NYCERS , via email, that they have to impose this requirement. He also effectively counters the operational objections that had been raised by NYCERS staff.

From 2000 to 2005 when I was executive director, there was no such filing requirement. The law was totally clear to me. If the Law Department had sent me such an email, I would have asked them to send a formal memo. I would have also told them that there would be a response from me notifying them that in my professional opinion that the law did not impose a five year requirement.

I would, however, have followed their advice but there would have been a legal record of my opposition. The Law Department hates that type of documentation. In reality it makes them back off writing garbage.

In the comments from the DC-37 trustee rep there is no support for the TWU position and only a deference to the Law Department. In particular, her reference to her "fiduciary hat" is laughable in light of the investment disasters for which that the trustees are responsible.

In the current executive director’s comments she contradicts what I said about how these applications were processed from 2000 to 2005. She claims that the five year requirement had been in effect for 11 years back to 2000. Since she was not at NYCERS during that time, she is not in position to personally know what happened during that time. Any information she gets from the NYCERS Legal Division is totally compromised by incompetence and lack of honesty.

Also from her comments, it appears to me that she was aggravated by the TWU’s rep’s initial inquiry about this issue and his persistence in following up on it.

A little background on the people involved. The TWU rep, Mr. Rosenfeld, worked for NYCERS for many years. I don’t have a high regard for him. In this case, however, he is totally correct in his position. I suspect he and Ms. D’Alessandro have had contact with each other over the years especially when she was the third string alternate for DC-37 on the Board of Trustees and he was working at NYCERS.

Toward the end of his comments Mr. Rosenfeld in support of his position claims that the attorney at the Law Department, who wrote the significant email, said to him "Norman, you are absolutely right. It's not in the law, but there is enough language we can hang our hat on." I’m afraid that quote says it all about what is happening to NYCERS members since 2005. If there is any way to screw the members, do it.

At the end of the July minutes, the Staten Island BP rep very correctly asked the Law Department for a formal legal memo on the issue to be presented at the next board meeting.

Guess what? You can see from the September minutes of the next board meeting that the TWU rep dropped his request and no formal memo was ever produced by the Law Department. Too bad for the veterans but the city saved a few dollars. Remember that NYCERS paid $183.3M in investment fees last year.

Why did TWU drop its request? Maybe you should read a posting I wrote in 2009 about a change in death benefits at the Transit Authority.

Note: The date of the last regular NYCERS meeting minutes posted on the Comptroller’s pension online web site is October 13, 2011. It was obviously too much transparency for NYCERS to handle.

July 14, 2011 Board Meeting

MS. D'ALESSANDRO (executive director):

Resolution Number 37.

The next item on the agenda is the proposed resolution regarding military service.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT (Chair, appointed by mayor):

Mr. Rosenfeld, I believe you wanted to speak about this?

MR. ROSENFELD (TWU, labor trustee):

Yes, Madam Chair.

TWU is proposing a change in the way NYCERS is processing military buybacks. Article 20 of the Social Security law basically is like a three-page law, it's very short. It basically says if you serve one day during a time of conflict and the conflicts are listed in the law, you can buy up to three years of military time. The law goes on to say that -- but you don't get credit until you have five years of service, excluding the military purchase.

Nowhere in the law does it say that you have to wait five years to pay for it. The law does prescribe how a veteran pays for it. It's 3 percent of the 12 months earned preceding NYCERS receiving the application multiplied by the number of years you're buying back. So if a person is making $80,000 back from when he submitted his application, $80,000 times 3 percent, $2400 times the number of years he is purchasing.

Now, NYCERS has been told, I understand, by the Law Department, that because of the wording in the law, that they make the veteran wait five years to pay for it. Therefore, it's costing the veteran more money. I've had some members of Local 100 come to me and complain about it, that they put into the military and they only had like two or three years on the job and they got a letter from NYCERS that they can't pay for them until they have the five years, thereby costing the veteran more money.

There's nothing in the law -- you've seen the proposal, I think it was e-mailed to everyone. There's nothing in the law that specifically states that you have to wait five years to pay for it, just an interpretation. Based on the Richter case that the Corp Counsel attorney advised us in May, any trustee can make a proposal to the board to change an operational procedure.

That's what TWU Local 100 is attempting to do. I think it would be a big win for all the principals involved, and I think it would be a big win for NYCERS in the forefront of all the other Retirement Systems who are processing the same way, they're making the veterans wait five years and thereby costing the veteran more money.

Who in this room wants to make a veteran pay more money for the military time? I know there are procedural things that NYCERS has to do and we need to discuss it. I understand some of the trustees, my fellow trustees, might want to think about it, but I'll leave it to the Madam Chair to decide what we're going to do with this.

Again, there is nothing in the law that says the veteran must wait five years to pay for it. All it says is you don't get credit till you have five years of credit, excluding the military purchase. I've been told that it could be a burden to NYCERS. What happens if the person doesn't make the five years?

Now NYCERS has to refund the money. But if the person doesn't make the five years, he's going to get a refund anyway if he requests it, thereby terminating his NYCERS membership and most of the time people hang in there, maybe hoping they'll get another city job and come back. Why would a person pay five years -- pay for his military and not plan on making a career?

So in my opinion, I don't see that as the problem for NYCERS, they'd have to process the refund anyway if the person wants to get a return of his accumulated deductions, they just add the military money which is in a separate account as well. That's my proposal.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:

Thank you, Mr. Rosenfeld. I have looked into this initially in addition to the Law Department's opinion that the NYCERS procedure is appropriate. I also understand that New York State processes requests in the same way, so that's one thing for the board to consider in looking at this resolution. I don't know if any other members of the board want to discuss or if they want to just take this under consideration and perhaps put it on the agenda for next month?

MR. ROSENFELD:

I'd be happy to take any questions from any trustee about it, if you have any questions.

MS. O'CONNELL (DC-37, labor trustee):

I think I do applaud TWU for taking the bull by the horns in trying to look at things with fresh eyes, I certainly applaud that.

My only concern is the fiduciary -- now putting on my fiduciary hat. If there is an opinion from the Law Department which I have not seen or read, which seems to say that Section 1000 requires waiting five years, I would like to hear, not necessarily today but maybe at the next board meeting -- regular board meeting not the investment meeting -- I'd like to hear from them a little more concerning that, a real analysis as to why this would essentially be violative of Section 1000.

Additionally, I would also suggest it might be good to hear from NYCERS in terms of operationally how these are processed. Maybe, again, at the next meeting. I applaud TWU for taking the initiative. I just think all the trustees would be well served to get the full picture before you vote on it.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:

I think that's an excellent point. I think Diane actually wants to share some information with us.

MS. D'ALESSANDRO:

I just wanted to inform the board that when Mr. Rosenfeld raised this issue, we did considerable amount of due diligence with respect to our process and external processes, and with respect to the law, it went into effect in the year 2000, and so we have been implementing in this manner for the past 11 years, and we have never really received a challenge up until this point.

So we looked at the law internally and we felt that we were administering it correctly. Then we subsequently polled various Retirement Systems throughout the state and have discovered that they also do it, from an administrative point of view, consistent with the way we do it.

And then when Mr. Rosenfeld raised it again, we pursued it with the Law Department and we spoke to Jay Cook directly with regard to it and he sent an e-mail essentially -- I will pass it out, but indicating that essentially we were doing it appropriately. So that's the information that I have at this point, and we've been acting on that opinion. So perhaps we'll just hand out Jay's e-mail, either that or give the board sometime to –

MR. ROSENFELD:

If I may just address Mr. Cook's e-mail. I spoke to Jay about this personally. And Jay said, "Norman, you are absolutely right. It's not in the law, but there is enough language we can hang our hat on."

So that's where I'm coming from. It's not in the law, but there is enough language, the language being that you don't get credit for five years so therefore make the veteran wait five years means making more money because most union members, they're on a stepped-up basis. They come in with this lower salary and they get step-ups and by the fifth year they're at full salary.

And therefore the same military purchase, if he would have purchased it after one year or two years, would have cost him much less money for the same military service. So as a veteran, I'm looking out for their -- and especially my own members, I've had two of them come to me and complain that they got letters and that was it, it was a dead issue as far as they're concerned, they got a letter from NYCERS saying "Sorry, you have to wait five years."

So why would they go back to NYCERS and question it? They get a letter saying, you know, you have to wait five years, that's it, it's a dead issue as far as they are concerned.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:

Mr. Zaccone?

MR. ZACCONE (rep for Staten Island Borough President):

I appreciate the e-mail that was passed around. I think it is really probably more equitable to the Law Department if we give them the opportunity to create a more formal memorandum as opposed to a short e-mail in response to the question.

So while that's helpful, I really think the Law Department owes us a more detailed analysis of this than a short memo here, and I'd ask that that be done. And if Diane can come back at the next regular meeting, along the lines of what Mary said, just on the procedures now in place and the procedures that may have to be put in place if there is a change.

MS. D'ALESSANDRO:

I'd be happy to do that.

MR. ZACCONE:

Thank you.

MR. SNOW (attorney from Law Department):

We'll follow through with that prior to the next regular meeting.

MR. ZACCONE:

Thank you.
CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:
Any further discussion on this?

MS. D'ALESSANDRO:

The next item on the agenda pertains …

September 10, 2011 Board Meeting

MS. D'ALESSANDRO:

That's Resolution Number 41.

The next item on the agenda pertains to a Law Department memorandum regarding the purchase of military credit under Section 1000; and that was in response to a proposed resolution by Mr. Rosenfeld.

MR. ROSENFELD:

Madam Chair, TWU respectfully is withdrawing this resolution. TWU would like to thank everyone for their time and consideration in this proposal, especially the Law Department. And despite the disagreement with the Law Department's opinion on how this law is being implemented by NYCERS, despite that, TWU feels that the legislative route is the best route to go. And I want to thank everyone for their time and consideration. We are officially withdrawing this resolution.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:

Thank you.

§ 1000. Military service credit.

Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, a member of a public retirement system of the state, as defined in subdivision twenty-three of section five hundred one of this chapter, shall be eligible for credit for military service as hereinafter provided:
1.
A member, upon application to such retirement system, may obtain a total not to exceed three years of service credit for up to three years of military duty, as defined in section two hundred forty-three of the military law, if the member was honorably discharged from the military and all or part of such military service was rendered during the following periods: (a)commencing December seventh, nineteen hundred forty-one and terminating December thirty-first, nineteen hundred forty-six; (b) commencing June twenty-seventh, nineteen hundred fifty and terminating January thirty-first, nineteen hundred fifty-five; or (c) commencing February twenty-eighth, nineteen hundred sixty-one and terminating May seventh, nineteen hundred seventy-five;
2.
A member, upon application to such retirement system, may obtain a total not to exceed three years of service credit for up to three years of military duty, as defined in section two hundred forty-three of the military law, if honorably discharged therefrom, if all or part of such services was rendered in the military conflicts referenced below, as follows: (a) hostilities participated in by the military forces of the United States in Lebanon, from the first day of June, nineteen hundred eighty-three to the first day of December, nineteen hundred eighty-seven, as established by receipt of the armed forces expeditionary medal, the navy expeditionary medal, or the marine corps expeditionary medal; (b) hostilities participated in by the military forces of the United States in Grenada, from the twenty-third day of October, nineteen hundred eighty-three to the twenty-first day of November, nineteen hundred eighty-three, as established by receipt of the armed forces expeditionary medal, the navy expeditionary medal, or the marine corps expeditionary medal; (c) hostilities participated in by the military forces of the United States in Panama, from the twentieth day of December, nineteen hundred eighty-nine to the thirty-first day of January, nineteen hundred ninety, as established by receipt of the armed forces expeditionary medal, the navy expeditionary medal, or the marine corps expeditionary medal; or (d) hostilities participated in by the military forces of the United States, from the second day of August, nineteen hundred ninety, to the end of such hostilities in case of a veteran who served in the theater of operations including Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Oman, the Gulf of Aden, the Gulf of Oman, the Persian Gulf, the Red Sea, and the airspace above these locations.
3.
A member must have at least five years of credited service (not including service granted hereunder) to be eligible to receive credit under this section.
4.
To obtain such credit, a member shall pay such retirement system, for deposit in the fund used to accumulate employer contributions, a sum equal to the product of the number of years of military service being claimed and three percent of such member's compensation earned during the twelve months of credited service immediately preceding the date that the member made application for credit pursuant to this section. If permitted by rule or regulation of the applicable retirement system, the member may pay such member costs by payroll deduction for a period which shall not exceed the time period of military service to be credited pursuant to this section. In the event the member leaves the employer payroll prior to completion of payment, he or she shall forward all remaining required payments to the appropriate retirement system prior to the effective date of retirement. If the full amount of such member costs is not paid to the appropriate retirement system prior to the member's retirement, the amount of service credited shall be proportional to the total amount of the payments made prior to retirement.
5.
In no event shall the credit granted pursuant to this section, when added to credit granted for military service with any retirement system of this state pursuant to this or any other provision of law, exceed a total of three years.
6.
To be eligible to receive credit for military service under this section, a member must make application for such credit before the effective date of retirement. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this subdivision, an individual who retired on or after December twenty-first, nineteen hundred ninety-eight and before the effective date of this section may make application for credit pursuant to this section within one year following the effective date of this section, in which event, the cost to the retiree would be based on the twelve month period immediately preceding retirement.
7.
All costs for service credited to a member pursuant to this section, other than the member costs set forth in subdivision three of this section, shall be paid by the state and all employers which participate in the retirement system in which such member is granted credit.
8.
A member who has purchased military service credit pursuant to section two hundred forty-four-a of the military law shall be entitled to a refund of the difference between the amount paid by the member for such purchase and the amount that would be payable if service had been purchased pursuant to this section.
9.
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in the event of death prior to retirement, amounts paid by the member for the purchase of military service credit pursuant to this section shall be refunded, with interest, to the extent the military service purchased with such amounts does not produce a greater death benefit than would have been payable had the member not purchased such credit. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in the event of retirement, amounts paid by the member for the purchase of military service credit pursuant to this section shall be refunded, with interest, to the extent the military service purchased with such amounts does not produce a greater retirement allowance than would have been payable had the member not purchased such credit.
10.
Anything to the contrary in subdivision four of this section notwithstanding, to obtain such credit, a member who first joins a public retirement system of the state on or after April first, two thousand twelve shall pay such retirement system, for deposit in the fund used to accumulate employer contributions, a sum equal to the product of the number of years of military service being claimed and six percent of such member's compensation earned during the twelve months of credited service immediately preceding the date that the member made application for credit pursuant to this section.

Monday, December 30, 2013

More Haze Over Long Island City

In September I wrote about the adoption of the NYCERS budget for FY-2014 at the March 14, 2013 NYCERS Board of Trustees meeting. I pointed out the scant reference to the issues surrounding the disaster recovery site at Long Island City (L.I.C.) in the executive director's written presentation on the budget. In a terse sentence she implied that the L.I.C. disaster recovery project was now functioning after an seven year delay.

I was curious whether any of the trustees had any questions at the meeting about this fiasco. So I made a FOIL request of the public minutes of the board meeting where the $52.2M budget was approved. This is the relevant exert form the minutes of the March 14, 2013 NYCERS Board of Trustees regular meeting:

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:
All in favor?
(A chorus of "Ayes.")
Any opposed?
Motion carries.
Item 2 on the agenda is a report by the budget committee, of which I am chair, so I will report on that.

I think NYCERS really did an incredible job presenting their budget to us. There was beautiful and substantively informative PowerPoint presentation. All of the really knowledgeable staff was there to answer any questions we had. For me, I think everything was in order.

I don't know if anybody on the budget committee or anybody else has any questions?

MS. O'CONNELL (DC-37):
A comment to echo your comments, Carolyn. I think Diane and staff did an excellent job of keeping the focus on member services, and also moving the institution forward in terms of technology and making progress in that regard. So I thank the executive director and staff for their efforts.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:
With that, a motion to approve the budget?

MS. D"ALESSANDRO(executive director):
...Then we move into the actual proposed budget for fiscal 2014 which is 2B(i) in your packet, and essentially it is the administrative budget for fiscal 2014 with $26,620,635 for PS expenses; $17,951,822 for other than personal expenses; qnd a total budget of $44,575,457 for fiscal 2014. (there is an additional $7.6M in fringe costs)

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:
Any questions on this resolution?
Is there a motion to approve?

MS. O'CONNELL:
Motion.

MS. STRYKER(Local 237, Teamsters):
Second.

CHAIRPERSON WOLPERT:
All in favor?
(A chorus of "Ayes.")
Any opposed?
Motion carries.

As you can see from the quoted text above, that there was no substantive discussion about this major expenditure. The text is devoid of any concrete information other than the fact that the regular NYCERS admin budget for FY-2014 will be $44.5M. (actually $52.2M)

One thing that caught my attention was the comment about the "beautiful and substantively informative PowerPoint presentation". I thought that it would be wonderful to read the presentation given to the budget committee. So I made a follow up FOIL request for it. That was on October 18, 2013. I made a second request on November 11, 2013 and on December 3, 2013 I received the following response from NYCERS.

Please be advised that your request under the Freedom of Information Law for NYCERS PowerPoint presentation outlining the FY-2014 administrative budget given to the Trustees budget committee is being denied.

The information you are seeking is considered inter-agency or intra-agency materials. Said materials were not presented to the Board of Trustees or listed as an Agenda Item at any NYCERS Regular/Investment meeting.

If you wish to appeal this denial, please contact Diane D’Alessandro, (Executive Director) of NYCERS.

It is clear to me that this reason for denial is evasive and incorrect. Listed below is the exact wording from the state web site about this specific reason for denying a FOIL request:

(g) are inter-agency or intra-agency communications, except to the extent that such materials consist of:
i. statistical or factual tabulations or data;
ii. instructions to staff that affect the public;
iii. final agency policy or determinations; or
iv. external audits, including but not limited to audits performed by the comptroller and the federal government;
As per the meeting minutes, the Chairperson points to the PowerPoint presentation as the basis of the budget committee's recommendation for approval of the proposed budget.I think it is safe to say the document was the basis of a final agency policy or determination, the adoption of the agency's $52.2M FY-2014 administrative budget.

In addition, I suspect that the Budget Committee falls under the N.Y.S. Open Meetings Law. That means material provided to the committee is public record. I don't think the committee had any reason to conduct its meeting in executive session.

Needless to say, while I will never see this PowerPoint presentation, I am sure that the N.Y.S. Department of Financial Services auditors will demand to see this presentation. They should also demand a physical inspection of the L.I.C. site and observe actual full disaster drill, not some empty "trust me" claim.

You would think that NYCERS management would have been anxious to provide the public a clear picture of the status of the Long Island City disaster recovery site. Now, because of this failure to disclose, it seems reasonable to conclude that the PowerPoint presentation is inaccurate and a poor basis for adopting the FY-2014 budget. Besides the mess at Long Island City what other disasters are the NYCERS management hiding.

Thursday, September 5, 2013

The Haze Over the Disaster Recovery Site at Long Island City - 2013

On March 14, 2013 the NYCERs Board of Trustees adopted resolutions approving the NYCERS administrative and loan operating budgets for FY-2014. The administrative budget was $44.6M with an added $7.6M for fringe benefits. The loan budget was $1.7M with $.3M for fringe benefits. The loan budget is totally paid by the active members through fees for loans. The executive director, Diane D’Alessandro, provided a two and a half page justification for these expenditures.

2011

In September 12, 2011 posting, I wrote about the fiasco surrounding the NYCERS disaster recovery (DR) site at Long Island City (LIC). At the time there was a five year delay in opening the DR site.

2012

In her February, 2012 justification for the FY-2013 NYCERS administrative budget D’Alessandro referred to the DR site issue as follows:

“The build-out of the business continuity site is nearing completion. Once the construction phase is finalized, the installation of the secondary data center will commence. This final phase will extend through FY-2103. Upon completion, the secondary data center will be equipped with a mainframe computer and have the capability for site-to-site data replication and data updating allowing for the eventual elimination of the Sterling Forest backup site. In an emergency, the LIC will have the capacity to house approximately 300 staff working on a two shift model. During normal business, the facility will be utilized for document management, training and IT testing and backup functions.“

In a July 13, 2012 posting, I commented on D’Alessandro’s failure to address the then six year delay in opening the LIC DR site and all the other problems surrounding this project.

2013

Part of the FY-2014 administrative budget is a $2.9M non payroll (OTPS) cost for maintaining the LIC DR site. In her FY-2014 budget justification D’Alessandro makes only the following mention of the LIC site:

“With the completion of the secondary data center at Long Island City (LIC), NYCERS will shift its focus to restructuring the Adams Street data center. Proposed upgrades will improve the utilization of space and enhance cooling, heating and air flow systems. This effort will provide greater energy efficiency, expanded storage capacity and improved functionality.”

From this terse comment you might assume that the DR site is fully functional. You will notice, however, that there is no mention of the actual completion date of the site, the award of a certificate of occupancy or the passage of fire inspection for the LIC site. There is also no mention of maximum occupancy for the site and there is no mention of a full operational test of the site. Remember the original 2006 lease renewal comes up in FY-2016, just two years away.

Given the history of this project it is quite possible that the site is not operational at all in spite of D’Alessandro’s attempt to give that impression. Of course it now seems that replacing the air conditioning unit in the computer room at Adams Street is the new hot item. At least, it appears that is what she is talking about. "Restructuring" and "Upgrades" are not words loaded with a lot of information.