The Phantom $600M and the Medicare Advantage Scam - Update

Phantom $600M

As the details about the Medicare Advantage scam have become clearer, one number keeps popping up, the $600M that the City is claiming it is going to save by ramming all the old retirees into a “Joe Namath” Medicare plan. The City, however, is not going to save anything. It is giving the money to the Health Insurance Stabilization Fund which is committed to city workers and pre-Medicare retirees. This is clearly a discriminatory benefits structure excluding Medicare retirees. The Fund is controlled by the city unions and the City. The NYC taxpayers have no control.

In addition, it appears that the $600M is an inflated number. As of June 30, 2021, there were 243,978 retirees that are eligible for city funded health insurance.

The Actuary's FY-2021 Retirees Benefit Report

As reported by the NYCERS Actuary in her 2021 Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB) report, this number breaks down into two main parts, 72,962 non-Medicare eligible participants (plus 46,483 spouses) and 171,016 Medicare eligible participants (plus 60,602 spouses).

The City saves nothing with respect to the 72,962 participants. They are not yet part of the scam. Their turn will come later.

The 171,016 Medicare retirees breaks down into four coverage groups:

1. GHI Senior Care 137,755
2. HIP VIP Medicare Advantage 18,127
3. Other (mostly Medicare Advantage) 6,905
4. Waived Coverage 8,229

Note: Emblemhealth controls both GHI Senior Care and HIP VIP as well as their companion products for workers and pre-Medicare retirees. The "Other" catergory is made up of an Aetna Medicare Advantage plan plus other minor carrires both Medicare Advanatge and Medicare Supplement plans.

Obviously, the City has never paid anything for the waived class. So, there are no new savings there.

HIP-VIP and the $7.50 Premium

The HIP and Aetna plans are strange situations. Out of the blue as of January 1, 2022 the City is only paying $7.50 per month per retiree for these two plans. Participants can stay in these plans with no change in their zero monthly premiums, but the City has been able to cut its cost from $184.95 and $204.53 per month to $7.50 with these two vendors. This is a real magic trick, the same coverage for almost no charge. Why didn’t the City do this years ago? Assuming all the "Other" class is covered by Aetna, this change produces a $54.96M annual savings.

1. 18,127 * ($184.95 - $7.50) * 12 = $38.60M
2. 6,905 * ($204.95 - $7.50) * 12 = $16.36M

The City has already started saving this $54.96M as of January 1, 2022. They have not been open about this savings but HIP and Aetna may back off their reductions after evaluating the court decision.

The GHI Senior Care Scam

Finally, let’s look at the big GHI Senior Care class of 137,755 participants. The coverage for this class is a Medicare supplemental insurance plan on top of traditional Medicare. If the participants in this class, however, want to keep their current coverage, the City is shifting $191.57 of its $199.07 per month cost to the retirees and their dependents. Prior to the court decision the City was planning to pay $7.50 per month for the GHI Senior Care plan. This is exactly the same amount that the City will be paying for the “Joe Namath” MAP plan being run by Emblemhealth and Anthem but only for the first year of the five year contract. The following years were going to be free.

This shift in costs would create a $316.68M annual savings (137,755 * ($199.07 - $7.50) * 12 = $316.68M) for the retirees.

Assuming that 67% of the spouses are covered by GHI Senior Care, also charging each of the spouses $191.57 creates a $91.95M annual savings (40,000 * ($199.07 - $7.50) * 12 = $91.95M).

In total, this creates a possible $463.599M annual savings ($54.96M + $316.68 + $91.95M). This is far short of the $600M. How did the City get this number so wrong?

Failed Strategy

In closing, the City has been very secretive about the internal costs figures for the Medicare Advantage scam. I suspect that the City was afraid that this information would expose what the City was doing with Emblemhealth.

Section 12-126 of the NYC Admin Code requires the City to pay the entire cost of health insurance up to 100% of the full cost HIP-HMO on a category basis. Category basis means individual or family. The City has tried to argue that law considers Medicare a category basis also.

After reading a 1995 report on the City's health insurance from the Citizens Budget Committee wriiten with the cooperation of OLR, I discovered that the City has, for many years, been using the GHI Senior Care premium as its cost control for Medicare retirees' health insurance. See the quote below:

The City's contribution for insurance for Medicare-eligible retirees is set at the premium cost for a GHI supplemental benefit policy, or $1,104 annually in fiscal year 1995. The City also pays an equal amount for coverage for a Medicare-eligible spouse of a retiree. If the spouse of a retiree is under age 65, the City pays the HIP rate for individual coverage ($1,780). A retiree and their spouse must choose the same plan if they are both Medicare- eligible or a plan from the same carrier if one is not Medicare-eligible.

I was able to match up the COBRA rates and retirees required premiums for six health insurance vendors for 2018, 2020 and 2021. The City started reporting COBRA rates for HIP-VIP in 2021. So 2021 has sven vendors.

For 2018 the City's cost was $172.42 for all plans, the full amount for GHI Senior Care. In 2020 the City's cost was $189.43. In 2021 the City's cost was $204.53, the full GHI Senior Care cost but the HIP-VIP cost was $184.95. It is clear that the City was using GHI Senior Care as its Section 12-126 cost control plan but was not being very public about it.

In addition to being deceptive about its cost limit for Medicare retirees, the City in order to circumvent the force of Section 12-126 of the NYC Admin Code had to get the HIP-VIP rate as close to zero as possible. It couldn't be zero because zero contracts are not valid. So the $7.50 rate was born. You see it in both of the Emblemhealth plans, the new MAP plan and the HIP-VIP plan.

The City only told the court about the new $7.50 premium on March 2, 2022, the day before the court made its decison. After testifying on March 1, 2022 and reviewing that testimony the following day, the City realized that in trying to hide its deal with Emblemhealth, it had also withheld the knowledge of the new $7.50 charge for HIP-VIP and without that knowledge, the court was going to disallow the $191.57 charge to the retirees.

The City's last minute go for broke strategy failed and the court decided against the City.

Aetna is a different story. I have another suspecion but it is not strong enough to comment on.

The City’s Failed Attempt to Steal from its Retirees and the Medicare Advantage Scam

NYC Admin Code Section 12-126 requires the City to “pay the entire cost of health insurance coverage for city workers, city retirees, and their dependents, not to exceed one hundred per cent of the full cost of H.I.P.-H.M.O. on a category basis.”. HIP-HMO is a Medicare Advantage plan managed by Emblemhealth. There are also other Medicare Advantage plans offered to NYC retirees. Medicare Advantage plans are not popular with NYC retirees, especially not retired teachers.

In 2021, the City introduced a new Medicare Advantage plan, the MAP plan, for retirees. The joint vendors for the contract for the new plan were Anthem and Emblemhealth. The only cost to the City for the new plan was a $7.50 monthly charge per participant for the first year of the five-year contract. This new plan was to be mandatory with a federally required opt out process. Part of the opt out, however, was that those retirees (GHI Senior Care) would have to pay $191.57 per month to stay in the GHI Senior Care plan. Prior to 1/1/2022 there was no charge for Senior Care.

On September 29, 2021, the retirees sued the City.

As of March 3, 2022, a state judge ordered the City to not charge the retirees the $191.57 monthly premium.

On the day before, March 2, 2022, the City for the first time notifies the court that Emblemhealth has dropped its monthly charge for HIP-VIP from $184.95 to $7.50 effective Jan. 1, 2022. Prior to 3/2/2022 the City had not notified the court of this reduction.

In its 3/21/2022 appeal papers the City claims that Emblemhealth did this “to retain market competitiveness”.

This is not credible because Emblemhealth was already offering the new MAP plan on a no cost basis and the HIP-HMO plan was a closed plan to new retirees. The more credible reason is that this would change the “100% full cost of HIP-HMO” cap and give the City a plausible excuse to start charging the retirees the $191.57 per month for the cost that was above the new HIP-VIP rate.

Why wait until the night before the court’s decision to reveal the $7.50 charge? I suspect that the City knew that if it had included the $7.50 change in its court filings, that the retirees would have attacked the City for circumventing the intent of the Section 12-126 and it would have exposed the City to credible charges of collusion with Emblemhealth.

Needles to say the City is trying to expedite its appeal to overturn the judge’s order and circumvent Section 12-126.

Anthem - US Department of Justice - Medicare Advantage Scam

I just stumbled on the following notice from DOJ. Within the press release you can find 112 page complaint. You can read the opening paragraph below:

Department of Justice
U.S. Attorney’s Office
Southern District of New York
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Friday, March 27, 2020

Manhattan U.S. Attorney Files Civil Fraud Suit Against Anthem, Inc., For Falsely Certifying The Accuracy Of Its Diagnosis Data

Geoffrey S. Berman, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, announced that the United States filed a civil fraud lawsuit today against ANTHEM, INC. (“ANTHEM”), alleging that ANTHEM falsely certified the accuracy of the diagnosis data it submitted to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) for risk-adjustment purposes under Medicare Part C and knowingly failed to delete inaccurate diagnosis codes. As a result of these acts, ANTHEM caused CMS to calculate the risk-adjustment payments to ANTHEM based on inaccurate, and inflated, diagnosis information, which enabled ANTHEM to obtain millions of dollars in Medicare funds to which it was not entitled.

Why is the notice significant? Well, Anthem is the company NYC has contracted with to ramrod NYC retirees into a Medicarae Part C plan (aka Medicare Advantage). You can read the opening of the proposed NYC/Anthem contract below. This raises serious questions about the integrity of this whole process.

Medicare Advantage Group Agreement

This NYC Medicare Advantage Plus Plan Group Agreement (hereinafter "MA Agreement") is entered into as of January 1, 2022 (hereinafter “Effective Date”) by and between

the City of New York (“City”) acting through Mayor’s Office of Labor Relations – Employee Benefits Program on behalf of the Labor Management Health Insurance Policy Committee for the New York City Health Benefits Program with an office at 22 Cortlandt Street, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10007 (hereinafter "Group") and

Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. doing business as Empire BlueCross BlueShield Retiree Solutions, on behalf of itself and the Alliance, defined below (hereinafter “Empire” or the “Alliance”) sponsor of the NYC Medicare Advantage Plus Plan (hereinafter "MA Plan"). Empire and The Group each are sometimes referred to herein as a “Party” and collectively as the “Parties.”

WHEREAS,

the City and Municipal Labor Committee (“MLC”), an umbrella organization for municipal unions, negotiate on a variety of matters, including collective bargaining regarding health benefits pursuant to their obligations under the New York Collective Bargaining Law;

WHEREAS,

to aid in the administration of the negotiated health benefits agreements, the City and the MLC established the Labor Management Health Insurance Policy Committee (“Committee”) for the MLC and City representatives to meet on a regular basis to discuss City health insurance benefits; and

WHEREAS,

the Employee Benefits Program (“EBP”) is a division of the Mayor’s Office of Labor Relations (“OLR”), and OLR is acting under the authority of the New York City Administrative Code Section 12.126(d) as the administrator of the New York City Health Benefits Program (“HBP”); and

WHEREAS,

on October 30, 2020 OLR’s request for authorization to enter into a Negotiated Acquisition to solicit a Medicare Advantage plan under Medicare Part C for the Medicare eligible retirees and dependents of the City of New York who are eligible for the City’s Health Benefits Program was approved by the City Chief Procurement Officer; and

WHEREAS,

OLR issued a public notice for a negotiated acquisition (EPIN:0021N002) in conformance with the New York City Procurement Policy Board Rules (“PPB”) and had otherwise advertised in order to solicit vendors through the Notice of Intent to provide health benefits services in the form of a Medicare Advantage plan under Medicare Part C for the Medicare eligible retirees and dependents of the City of New York who are eligible for the City’s Health Benefits Program; and

WHEREAS,

the Retiree Health Alliance (“the Alliance”), a strategic alliance between Empire and EmblemHealth Plan, Inc. (“EmblemHealth”) and their affiliates, submitted a response for such services, as provided for in the public notice for a negotiated acquisition, in the form of an expression of interest to OLR; responses were evaluated by an evaluation committee pursuant to PPB Section 3-04; and

WHEREAS,

OLR determined the Alliance’s proposal to be most advantageous to the City, taking into consideration technical expertise, price, contract terms, M/WBE Utilization Plan and other factors set forth in the negotiated acquisition solicitation; and

WHEREAS,

the City desires to appoint the Alliance to provide a Medicare Advantage Plan Under Medicare Part C for City of New York Retirees, and their Dependents, and

NOW, THEREFORE,

in consideration of the terms and conditions contained herein, the parties hereby agree as follows:

  ARTICLE 1 - PURPOSE
The Alliance will provide health insurance coverage to the Group’s eligible retirees and other eligible individuals as described in this MA Agreement. Empire is accountable for the operations, compliance, and performance of the MA Plan. EmblemHealth is an entity contracting with Empire to administer portions of this co-branded product to help ensure the City’s retirees receive continuity of care and membership support.

Specifically, EmblemHealth will co-manage the account, provide a professional network in the downstate New York area, deliver care through Neighborhood Health Centers, and support Empire in multiple areas of plan performance. ...